A new book on Niagara Falls suggests the world-famous destination is a prime example of how America has controlled nature, despoiled it and shrouded the wrongdoing in myth.
The curious title is an obvious attempt to convince any browser that this book is different from others that focus on the Cataract City and its major attraction: “Inventing Niagara: Beauty, Power, and Lies,” by Ginger Strand (Simon & Schuster, 337 pages, $25, hardcover).
For millions of tourists who stroll through the Niagara Falls State Park every year, the words “beauty” and “power” easily come to mind. That’s an instant and, few would argue, an accurate impression.
But what’s with the “Lies?”
In a word, Strand intensely dislikes the idea of diverting water to produce power, reshaping of the riverbed, and the stabilizing of the brink to prevent future rockslides. That tampering plus all the fake stuff within walking distance of the falls — the wax museums, the haunted houses and the mind-bogging Indian tales — makes us a virtual center of deception, according to the author.
One of Strand’s most critical observations is hardly a boost for the approaching tourist season: “Niagara is a breathtaking landmark larded with falsification, prevarication and omission.”
After all, who would want to come here on vacation?
Maybe she has a point that Niagara as a true natural wonder does not exist anymore but try telling that to the millions of camera-toting visitors who pour through Prospect Park from late May to late September, the travel writers from around the globe, the film production companies and the honeymooners., to name a few.
If it’s half as fake as Strand infers, then surely there is someone smarter than P.T. Barnum behind the scenes, turning the tap on and off.
With so many books written about Niagara, even in the past 20 years, what made the author think there was anything more to say?
“I realized there was a hidden history that hadn’t been talked about at all — landscape alterations, fugitive slaves, the Manhattan Project, on going toxic dumping,” Strand said.
Certainly, the natural and physical changes to the falls and adjacent parklands have been thoroughly documented over the decades.
The stories of fugitive slaves escaping via the Underground Railroad are vividly recounted in many histories at libraries in Niagara and Erie counties and even in newspaper archives. (The Niagara Gazette published a 12-part series based on the research of a reporter-photographer team that traveled more than 1,000 miles tracing the route of three runaway slaves from Virginia to the border at Niagara.
As for toxic dumping, the problems have hardly been hidden from the summer of 1978, when reporter Mike Brown started investigating the chemically contaminated neighborhood called Love Canal.
Subsequently, the media explored every conceivable follow-up to that environmental disaster. Admittedly, there still are still nightmares of industrial pollution but not in the LaSalle neighborhood that made headlines across the country.
Still, Strand’s book will probably fly off the shelves. People like to read about coverups, false advertising and Native American myths.
•••
FOOTNOTES: Despite some flaws, Strand’s book is readable and will undoubtedly jog a lot of memories for local residents as well as tourists who may have visited the natural wonder years ago. The cover is indeed eye catching and creative, which should spur sales.
Closer to the homefront, however, a sampling of how Strand describes a few familiar persons in this community:
n Maureen Fennie, local history department manager at the Brydges Library: “....skirted, bespectacled and usually sporting a strikingly arty piece of jewelry, she looks like she arrived from central casting after someone ordered up a librarian.” She also is a “sharp-eyed observer of local affairs,” the author found.
n Paul Gromosiak, local historian and author: “...an affable, white-haired man with the face of a Norman Rockwell schoolboy.”
Gromosiak dislikes how the flow to the falls has been so sharply reduced.
n Bob Baxter of the Niagara Heritage Partnership and ardent supporter of returning a section of the Moses Parkway to green space: “....He has a single gray curl in the middle of his forehead, a perfect tube where he could stick a cigarette for safekeeping, and he seems the kind of person who might do that.”
n Jacob Sherman, manager of the Maid of the Mist souvenir store in the Niagara Falls State Park: “...in a shirt and tie, a silver pen perfectly tucked into his shirt pocket, he presides over a pin-neat store: shot glasses and souvenir mugs lined up in regiments and T-shirts stacked in order of size.” Sherman’s family owned and operated the former Niagara Falls Museum for many years.
Contact reporter Don Glynn at 282-2311, ext. 2246.
Columns
GLYNN: Author says world famous Niagara Falls has lost its luster
- Columns
-
-
HAMILTON: The SPCA and the pineapple upside-down pie
It is said that, as free Americans, we often get the things for which we ask; we also often get exactly what we deserve. Sometimes it works out to our good, and sometimes it doesn’t.
-
GLYNN: Slim chance now for a real thick ice bridge
If you’re not convinced about the unpredictability of Western New York weather, consider that this area was experiencing temperatures in the mid-40s on the 100th anniversary of the ice bridge tragedy in the gorge.
-
BRADBERRY: Is Black History Month Still Relevant?
I am uncomfortably recovering and slowly recuperating from a relatively minor, but medically necessary procedure which has kept me out of circulation, out of touch and essentially on my back for a lot longer than I have personally believed was justifiable; however, in this case my opinion matters not; the doctor’s diagnosis and promising prognosis trumped mine, so here I lay almost completely befuddled, nearly unable to pen a clear sentence.
-
CONFER: Time to end the NFL’s blackout rule
Long ago, in a much simpler time, ticket sales accounted for the majority of revenues for professional football teams.
-
CITY BEAT: Stuck on traffic
Sometimes I feel like the traffic signal reporter in Niagara Falls.
Traffic signals have been making a lot of news around here lately. There’s the whole flap about what to do to improve public safety near the Como Restaurant in the 2200 block of Pine Avenue. -
HIGGS: Discussing crime and punishment in the Falls
Have to take a detour off Pine Avenue in 1956 this week to report on an event held by the Niagara Falls Block Club Council for its member clubs and other interested citizens.
-
GLYNN: Hotel Niagara plan exciting for the Falls
It all sounds like a re-run of a TV program you’ve seen a dozen times. This time, however, there is every reason to believe that the landmark Hotel Niagara on Rainbow Boulevard will be restored to the splendid atmosphere that guests enjoyed for decades.
-
HAMILTON: BOE and kids, or the SPCA dogs?
There is example after example of otherwise qualified Niagara Falls’ board of education members and staffers lending their time and efforts to organizations outside of the school district’s core business.
-
GLYNN: Trust in SPCA shelter must be restored
Stories about the operations at the Niagara SPCA shelter shape the image of sickening and disgusting treatment of animals.
-
BRADBERRY: Old medicine and new challenges
Having suffered and recovered from my fair share of illnesses and injuries over the years, I have come to believe that sometimes the treatment and the cure of my condition can seem to be far worse than whatever I may think is ailing me at the moment.
- More Columns Headlines
-






