As far as Joseph Barrett is concerned, the ice boom put in place on Lake Erie every year isn’t just holding back the ice, it’s holding back the development of the Niagara River.
Barrett, a serious fisherman and amateur scientist, has spent more than a decade striving to prove environmental degradation at the mouth of the lake and along the Niagara River is the result of inhibited ice flow. The New York Power Authority’s massive ice boom at the mouth of the river, he says, keeps tons of nutrient-laden ice from traveling through to Lake Ontario each year — and to the thousands of tiny ecosystems along the way.
“He’s raised an entirely new theory on the river which scientists haven’t raised in the past,” said Julie O’Neill, executive director of the Buffalo/Niagara Riverkeeper.
In fact, the 50 years the boom has been in place may actually have set the table for science to learn more about how ice floes contribute to the environment. Because studies have not been done, however, most are left to guess what would happen to marinas, private docks, homes and other riverfront property in the face of a natural ice floe.
O’Neill said the group is willing to talk to such scientists if they can secure the funding — a common response by those whose interest has been piqued — but that a lot of research still needs to be done in order to answer the first two questions: What ecological impact the boom has and, if there are negative consequences, what can be done about them?
“There’s always an ecological consequence,” O’Neill said. “There just isn’t research on the effect of the boom on sedimentation patterns.”
According to Barrett’s research, erosion partially accounts for Strawberry Island’s rapid decrease from about 100 acres to just 3 over the last several decades. He says it can be laid to inhibited ice, which he said would otherwise plow sediment back against its banks over time.
Though it’s important to note that more than a century’s worth of digging, soil replacement and other engineering have all come into play on the island that has a storied past.
Elsewhere along the banks of the West River, trees are falling into the water in the absence of any shoreline. Barrett again claims scouring of the river floor by the ice would plow sandy material up against the banks, providing a buffer between the now exposed roots and swift current.
“If you didn’t know what it was supposed to look like, you’d think you were in the swamps of Louisiana but these trees aren’t meant to germinate in the water. These are regular deciduous trees,” he said, noting he desires only that his claims be offered a chance for scrutiny by his peers.
Barrett also points to a gradual broadening of the river floor in the absence of mechanical weathering by the ice.
Then there’s the slime.
Detritus, he said it’s called, the stuff that in aerial photographs highlights the Queen City’s lake with a rim of green. Barrett said it’s just one more consequence of holding back the ice, leading to the formation of botulism he believes is responsible for about 9,000 fish that washed up dead or dying on Woodlawn Beach recently.
Riverkeeper’s O’Neill calls it “rock-snot,” an invasive species, accounts for the color more than anything else, but said if you take the leap to say Barrett’s theory is correct — if the studies are done — inhibiting the cycle could allow the material to stagnate, adding to the general detritus.
“We want our river back. We don’t want to deal with botulism outbreaks anymore, we don’t want Strawberry Island to disappear,” Barrett said.
Communities
Related Photos
-
Joe Barrett is a vocal opponent of the ice boom, ice from which can be seen at rear against the inner-harbor breakwall Wednesday. DOUG BENZ/STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER
ICE BOOM: Amateur scientist says barrier hurts river
- Communities
-
-
Black History Month celebrated at Mount St. Mary's
February is Black History Month, and the administration at Mount St. Mary’s Hospital took time Thursday to honor some of its employees of color and their contributions.
-
Lockport man scratches his way to $1 million
Paul Schneider had just gotten off the phone with his girlfriend when he called her back with some amazing news.
-
Help sought for Falls after-prom party
The organizers of the Niagara Falls High School Post Prom Party are looking for a few good parents.
-
State looking for good ideas on Schoellkopf Hall
The state is looking for help in restoring historic Schoellkopf Hall at DeVeaux Woods State Park.
-
Rescued pets featured on 2012 cat calendar
A dog and cat rescued by a Niagara Falls couple have are featured in a page-a-day animal calendar.
-
SLIDESHOW: Niagara Charter School
Niagara Charter School opened with an initial enrollment of 264 students in grades kindergarten through fourth. The school has added fifth and sixth grade students since then and this year has an enrollment of about 350 students. This year, staff members are preparing to prove to the State Education Department that it made the right choice in allowing them to open the doors back in 2006.
-
HYDRO to hold inaugural meeting at Giacomo Thursday
A new group called HYDRO Niagara Falls is holding its first meeting at 7:30 p.m. today at the Giacomo Hotel, 222 First St.
-
Relay For Life kicking off fourth year at Hard Rock
A celebration to kick off the fourth annual American Cancer Society Relay For Life event in Niagara Falls will be held from 5 to 7 p.m. today at the Hard Rock Cafe, 333 Prospect St.
-
‘Burning’ questions about Lewiston author's new book
Lewiston resident and accomplished author Norah Perez had a story floating around in the deep recesses of her mind. She just needed someone to take a gamble and allow her to publish it.
-
Emily Lauzonis ‘pooling’ her talents to raise funds at Lew-Port
Emily Lauzonis, a Lewiston-Porter Intermediate student, had one goal this year when it came to the Swim A Cross event which benefits the American Red Cross. She simply wanted to break her totals raised from the 2011 version.
- More Communities Headlines
-
Killer of Fla. Girl Found in Landfill Gets Life
Army Orders Bradley Manning Court-martial
Cancer Charity Revives Breast-screening Grants
Heavy Snowstorm Hits Colorado On Its Way East
2nd Teacher From LA School Arrested on Sex Claim
Prosecutors Close Armstrong Inquiry, No Charges
Sights and Sounds: Football Fans Pour Into Indy
Unemployment Rate Down to 8.3%
Obama: Still Far Too Many Americans Need Jobs
GOP: Jobs Numbers Welcome, Can Do Better
Fla. Man Adopts Girlfriend in Legal Battle
More Deaths As Egypt Clashes Continue
Raw Video: Prince William in Falklands
Egpyt Protesters Blame Police for Soccer Deaths
'Lucky' 9-Year-Old Receives 6-Organ Transplant
Raw Video: Michelle Vs. Ellen in Pushup Contest
First Person: Will Peyton Manning Stay in Indy?
Egypt Shaken After Deadly Soccer Riot
New Suits, New Starts for New York's Unemployed
Hall of Famer Dorsett Speaks Out on NFL Injuries
