In a pair of decisions, a U.S. Magistrate judge has recommended to deny a move by attorneys for suspended Falls police officer Ryan Warme to have several counts of a federal corruption indictment against him dismissed, but has sent his request for two separate trials to a U.S. District Court judge for a ruling.
Magistrate Hugh Scott rejected claims by Warme’s attorneys that some of the charges lodged against him were unconstitutional. At the same time, he concluded that a request for two separate trials, one on alleged sex crimes and another on gun and drug crimes be sent to Chief U.S. District Court Judge Richard Arcara for review.
Defense attorney Joel Daniels had argued to Scott that Warme needed to have two trials to protect his rights. Prosecutors told Scott that Warme should only get a single trial because all the charges against him are “bundled together.”
Warme is accused of violating the civil rights of three women by sexually assaulting or abusing them, using his position as a police officer to extort sexual favors from a Falls prostitute, conspiring to distribute both powdered and crack cocaine, committing federal firearms offenses and failing to arrest a known felon who was in possession of a weapon.
Daniels had asked Scott to recommend two trials because Warme wants to testify in his own defense on the sex crimes, but not on the drug and gun crimes.
“(Warme) says, ‘I am willing to testify in the sex cases, but I am asserting my Fifth Amendment right (against self incrimination) on the drugs and guns’,” Daniels said. “We believe the grounds are there and the law is on our side in this (judicial) district.”
In a one sentence ruling, Scott wrote that issue should be decided by Arcara, who would eventually try the case.
“Such motions are more appropriately heard and determined by the trial court,” Scott wrote. “Which is in the best position to rule on the issues presented.”
Warme’s defense team has also asked Scott to recommend dismissal three of the 11 counts in the federal indictment he faces. Among other claims, Daniels had argued that Warme could not be charged with a crime (under the Hobbs Act) that relates to obtaining “property” through extortion, when the “property” is an act of oral sex.
“The United States Supreme Court has ruled that property is ‘something you can exchange, transfer or sell,’ ” Daniels told Scott. “(Oral sex) is a completed act. There’s nothing left to transfer. This is not property.”
Scott, however, disagreed.
“Warme allegedly did receive something of value from Victim 4, notwithstanding the illegal nature of the service provided,” the magistrate wrote. “Theoretically, Warme could have transferred or sold the service to another (by forcing Victim 4 to perform the service for someone other than himself), but according to the indictment in this case, utilized the service for himself.”
“We will appeal and we will file our objections with Judge Arcara,” Daniels said after Scott’s recommendation was filed. Arcara has given Daniels until Oct. 15 to file his appeal.
Courts
COURTS: Mixed ruling for Warme
Federal magistrate rules against dismissing indictment counts, but sends request for two trials to higher court
- Courts
-
-
Davis will not seek Murphy removal
Lawyers for accused killer Matthew “Bones” Davis say their client will not ask to have Niagara County Court Judge Matthew J. Murphy III removed from his case.
-
Man charged in Casal attack says Falls boxer was the aggressor
An assault charge filed against a Town of Niagara man accused of attacking Niagara Falls boxer Nick Casal is heading to the grand jury.
-
Falls teen reaches agreement in shooting death of student
A Niagara Falls teenager has accepted a plea agreement in the shooting death of a Niagara University student who was killed in a “robbery gone bad” late last year.
-
Judge may step down in murder case
Lawyers for accused killer Matthew "Bones" Davis will have 10 days to decide whether or not they will ask Niagara County Court Judge Matthew J. Murphy III to step down from the case.
-
NT drug dealer gets 92-month sentence
The North Tonawanda man guilty of helping run a cocaine ring stretching from the Town of Tonawanda to Niagara Falls will spend nearly the next eight years behind bars.
-
Lewiston jet boat suit tossed
The second of two lawsuits brought against the Village of Lewiston and Whirlpool Jet Boat Tours has been dismissed.
-
Matthew Davis arraigned in Bradberry homicide case
When Robert Bradberry walked into a Niagara County courtroom Tuesday afternoon, he was surprised by the man he saw in shackles and an orange jumpsuit.
-
Sixth delay granted in Toohey case
Sentencing in federal court for a disbarred Lewiston lawyer has now been postponed for the sixth time.
-
Ten-year term for former Falls sub who had sex with a student
His victim’s mother called him “a monster.”
She also told John Summerson, that if should ever “have children”, she hoped “he never has to feel what I feel.” -
Former coroner, fire chief fined, to perform community service
Former Fourth District Coroner Russell Jackman and soon-to-be-former Cambria Volunteer Fire Co. Chief Vincent Salerno will each pay a fine totaling $1,000 and perform 100 hours of community service for their improper handling of human remains after a traffic fatality last month.
- More Courts Headlines
-
Calif.'s Coronado Named Nation's Best Beach
CEO Salaries Become Sore Issue in Labor Disputes
Raw Video: Fight Erupts in Ukrainian Parliament
Texan Ranchers Remain Wary of Drought
Raw Video: Soldiers Plant Flags at Arlington
NJ Official: NYPD Muslim Surveillance Legal
Police: Man Arrested in Etan Patz Disappearance
Hurricane Forecast: 15 Named Storms Expected
NYC Protests: the Revolution Will Be Scripted
Chicago U.S. Attorney Fitzgerald Resigns
Neighbors of Etan Patz's Suspect: It's Shocking
Search Intensifies for Missing Louisiana Woman
Bloomberg: Man Implicates Self in Etan Patz Case
NYPD: Person Implicated in Etan Patz Death
Raw Video: Fire on Nuke-powered Sub in Maine
Illegal Burn Suspected in Nevada Fire
Obama: 'We've Got More Work to Do'
Astrologers Predict Outcome of Presidential Race
Gulf Fishermen Reel From Seafood Troubles
Stuntman Makes Skydive Without Parachute in UK
