Niagara Gazette

Editorials

September 1, 2009

EDITORIAL: Tread carefully on state reform

The abysmal failure of the current state government in Albany has provoked an understandable outcry for reform.

In the heat of debate, irate citizens have offered remedies running the gamut from “throw-all-incumbents-out and start over” to a constitutional convention to rewrite the coveted document that has shaped New Yorkers lives for centuries.

The tumult and shouting over the dysfunctional structure that has virtually paralyzed activity on Capitol Hill for months is thoroughly justified.

The very voters screaming that they’re fed up and won’t take it anymore are in the position to spur long-overdue change.

Recent polls make it abundantly clear that nearly 50 percent of the eligible voters are so upset by all the shenanigans in Albany that they would not hesitate for a moment to turn their own state senator out of office in 2010.

That’s a refreshing change from earlier times when dissatisfied voters were often reluctant to vote against their own senator. After all, many voters convinced themselves their representative in Albany was doing the best possible job.

Things could change, of course, within the next 14 months, but the lawmakers in both houses would have to adopt an entirely different attitude toward the way they conduct business.

Today, those same voters are apparently weighing yet another approach to fixing the broken system: a constitutional convention.

At a glance that might seem a viable option but voters need to be wary of the inherent pitfalls as well.

In 1997, the last time that voters even considered the proposal for a convention, the measure was trounced by a coalition of conservative activists, labor unions and environmental groups encouraged by state lawmakers who traditionally abhor any idea of changing the power structure in Albany.

If voters really believe that a constitutional convention would bring needed reform, they should at least demand incumbent lawmakers be excluded from the process.

Since the delegates are paid — as they should be — the incumbents would end up with a second salary, hardly what a state mired in a fiscal crisis needs.

A constitutional convention is bound to fail if professional politicians are put in charge.

Editorials

Featured Ads

Section Teases

AP Video

Night & Day

Opinion

House Ads

Twitter News

Follow me on Twitter

Seasonal Content

Hyperlocal Search

Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Front page

Poll

Do you think local and county officials will have a Niagara Falls to Lewiston tourist trolley up and running for the summer?

Yes. It’s too good of an idea to pass up, they’ll find a way.
No. They haven’t even figured out how to pay for it yet, there’s not enough time before summer starts.
Ready with my token. It’s kind of a longshot but I have hope.
     View Results