Local News
COURTS: Maid of the Mist lawsuit dismissed
Atlanta businessman to continue legal fight
A long-time critic of Maid of the Mist Corp. is vowing to fight an Albany County judge’s decision to dismiss his challenge of an agreement between the tour boat operator and the New York State Office of Parks.
Atlanta businessman William Windsor, who filed a lawsuit in an attempt to void Maid’s 40-year concession agreement with the state, said he will file a motion to vacate the order of State Supreme Court Justice Joseph Teresi who on Monday dismissed Windsor’s claim as untimely. Windsor maintains that Teresi made a “key error in the facts” in the case.
“I hope the judge realizes his error,” Windsor said. “If not, I will appeal.”
In a ruling issued earlier this week, Teresi determined that Windsor missed his opportunity to challenge Maid’s New York state concession agreement.
The deal was awarded to Maid of the Mist in 2002 without a formal bid process. State parks officials have since argued it was not necessary for them to solicit bids for the lease because Maid of the Mist is considered a “sole-source provider” of tour boat operations on the Niagara River near Niagara Falls.
Teresi dismissed Windsor’s claim on the basis of timeliness, ruling that he failed to meet a four-month statute of limitations placed on challenges to the licensing agreement. In his ruling, Teresi said the start date for the statute of limitations was the date of the signing of the lease — Sept. 10, 2002. As a result, Teresi determined that Windsor had until Nov. 20, 2009, to issue a challenge.
“Since the petition was commenced more than four months after the lease was signed by the Maid and the state, it is untimely and must be dismissed,” Teresi’s decision reads.
Teresi also deemed Windsor’s complaints about “fraud, misrepresentation, conspiracy and a violation of due process” on the part of certain Maid officials as untimely, saying they were not raised within the six-year statute of limitations for commencement of such proceedings.
Maid of the Mist Vice President Tim Ruddy said the ruling speaks for itself.
“We are pleased that yet another legal decision has confirmed that the Maid of the Mist’s business is completely legitimate and we look forward to once again hosting millions of Niagara Falls visitors on both sides of the border this summer,” he said.
Windsor insists that he isn’t through with the case. He disagrees with Teresi’s finding that the statute of limitations had passed, arguing that the timing of the statute should be based on his discovery of issues related to the issuance of the licensing agreement.
“The facts before the court show that I was unaware of any fraud until April 1, 2009, despite numerous requests to obtain copies of the documents,” Windsor said. “If you file legal requests for production of documents, freedom of information requests, and contact everyone you can think of and can't get a copy of the document, then you cannot possible know there is fraud. The clock cannot start ticking on the two year fraud statute of limitations until April 1, 2009.”
- Local News
-
-
SLIDESHOW: New Niagara USA Visitors Center
Slideshow of the New Niagara USA Visitors Center.
-
AP Sources: Silver, Sampson plan SUNY compromise
A state official involved in the negotiations says Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver and Senate leader John Sampson are crafting a bill that would empower the state’s public universities to grow unfettered by Albany and allow them greater control over raising tuition.
-
Ethics panel accuses Rangel of 13 violations
A House investigatory panel is alleging 13 violations of congressional ethics and federal law statutes by veteran New York Rep. Charles Rangel.
-
Track set for new Falls train station
The project has been in various stages of discussion in Niagara Falls since the late 1980s.
-
Violante pleads the Fifth on DWI case
Niagara County District Attorney Michael Violante won’t explain why he allowed the daughter of an elected official to avoid a DWI charge last week in a rare plea deal in North Tonawanda City Court.
-
State judge defends court’s handling of case
State Supreme Court Judge Richard Kloch on Wednesday defended the decision of North Tonawanda City Court Judge William Lewis last week to accept a plea deal that spared the daughter of a North Tonawanda councilwoman a DWI trial.
-
District Attorney Michael Violante's statement on Donovan case
The following is an exact transcript of Niagara County District Attorney Michael Violante’s press release issued Wednesday in response to public criticism of a plea deal he offered to the daughter of North Tonawanda Alderwoman Nancy Donovan. Sara E. Donovan was arrested for DWI earlier this month after a one-car accident but instead pleaded guilty to a parking ticket and a speeding ticket.
-
Olive Garden plan approved for Falls
Niagara Falls is one step closer to getting an Olive Garden restaurant.
Members of the city’s planning board on Wednesday approved a site plan for a proposal to build a new Olive Garden near the main entrance to the Walmart plaza off Military Road in LaSalle. -
Questions remain over LaSalle library historic designation proposal
Members of the Niagara Falls Library Board want to discuss a few more details before they agree to lend their support to plans for designating the LaSalle Library building as an historic site.
-
Unusual Special Olympics event set for Seneca Niagara Casino
If everything goes as planned, those little things dangling over the edge of the Seneca Niagara Casino today will be brave volunteers raising funds for the Special Olympics.
- More Local News Headlines
-
