NORTH TONAWANDA: Malpractice award is more than $9 million

Local News

July 14, 2008

2004 death of 33-year-old partially attributed to negligence

Staff Reports The Niagara Gazette Mon Jul 14, 2008, 06:45 PM EDT

More than $9 million awarded by a Niagara County jury, who deemed the death of a 33-year-old North Tonawanda woman due to negligence on the part of her physician, is perhaps the largest such figure in the court’s history.

Malpractice insurance is expected to cover court-ordered payments to the husband and two children of Suzanne E. Crane, whose 2004 death is being partially attributed to negligence on the part of a famed Western New York surgeon with almost 50 years experience, Nancy J. Stubbe.

The total, $9,057,000, includes retroactive damages and other “pecuniary” compensation for the period of time following Crane’s death to the present, and into the future, according to documents filed with the Niagara County clerk.

Of 10 separate allocations set for distribution among the three family members listed in the suit and Crane’s estate, the largest single figure is to her husband, Raymond Crane, for future losses in the amount of $3,030,160.00.

The jury decided that figure would compensate him for a period of time up to 10 years from the time the verdict was handed up June 30. An additional $1 million was included to cover the period between his wife’s death and the verdict being reached.

An additional $1,027,800.00 was split between funeral expenses, pain and suffering and loss of services. Another $4 million in total covers each of the two children in equal parts for between the next 17 to 20 years.

Stubbe, 77, was previously nominated by Rep. Thomas M. Reynolds as a “local legend of medicine.” A biography posted on the Web at that time includes statements from Stubbe.

She earned her M.D. from the Women’s Medical College of Pennsylvania in 1958.

In 1963, information from www.nlm.nih.gov states she became a member of the Buffalo Medical Center. Four years later she became clinical instructor, and years later clinical assistant professor, at SUNY Buffalo’s School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences.

At that time she was also a fellow with the American College of Surgeons and in 1978 began a two-year tenure as president of the Erie County chapter of the American Cancer Society.

Over the course of the next 24 years, she was named Woman Physician of the year, 2000, by Kaleida Health System, co-founded the Acute Crisis Committee at Erie County Medical Society and was honored several times by area colleges for her contributions to local medicine.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Local News

No new vet for Niagara SPCA
It was one step forward and one step back for the SPCA of Niagara on Monday.
Just 72 hours after announcing the hiring of a new veterinarian for its troubled shelter, the SPCA board changed its mind and decided not to bring Lewiston vet Dr. Grant Hobika on board.

February 6, 2012 1 Photo
Tough time for NIMAC to ask for city funds
City officials say they are committed to helping continue military operations at the Niagara Falls Air Reserve Station.
Just how much money the city of Niagara Falls will be able to pledge remains a question.

February 6, 2012
Library board appointment vote put on hold
A request from Mayor Paul Dyster’s administration to appoint former city council candidate Alicia Laible to the library board did not come up for a vote as expected during Monday’s council meeting.

February 6, 2012
Landlord registration law comes under fire in the Falls
Community leaders are looking for a change in a landlord registration law they helpd create two years ago.

February 6, 2012
Forster officially seeking Dem chairmanship
Former Niagara County Party Chairman Nicholas Forster made it official on Monday.

February 6, 2012
Hayes sentence delayed in homicide case
Wilbert Hayes III was behind bars on Monday but not to begin serving his sentence for the slaying of Donald Tyree Nix.

February 6, 2012
NT coach fired for relations with student
A 25-year-old substitute teacher and coach has been fired by the North Tonawanda School District after an investigation into an inappropriate relationship with a 17-year-old female student.

February 6, 2012
Senate passes school bus legislation
The state Senate passed a series of school bus bills on Monday that leaders say will increase safety and communication.

February 6, 2012
In Lockport, Man faces extradition in Vegas fraud
A former Las Vegas resident picked up at the U.S.-Canadian border on Nevada securities fraud charges was ordered held for extradition from New York on Monday, after a judge rejected his claim of diplomatic immunity.

February 6, 2012
Falls woman brings low-cost spay and neutering program to area
Celia Trapasso noticed a disturbing trend in Niagara Falls.
The pet owner and animal lover saw far too many animals — particularly cats — running the streets in the city.

February 5, 2012 2 Photos
More Local News Headlines

Do you think cigarette sales to non-Native American customers should be taxed on reservations?